External Li Battery Upgrade Install Concept

K7MDL

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2009
Posts
308
Location
Snohomish, WA
I have a 50Ah LiFePO4 battery and 50amp capable waterproof DC-DC converter with integrated solar charger today for my ham radio battery needs. I use them in the truck cab today, tapping off the 6GA cable run between the camper and the alternator so that the camper batteries can power my radio gear.

The charger will eventually be used to charge the camper batteries when the time comes to replace the pair of AGMs. They are not even 3 years old yet, so I am not in a hurry allowing some time to consider my approach.

I have a 2022 front dinette model Hawk, so the batteries are located aft of my rear axle and are heavy reducing my available hitch weight and rear axle capacity. With the batteries in the back today, the stock camper 10AWG wiring is relatively long and I have significant voltage drop. Upgrading the wire size for faster charging requires running that new cable through the cabinets or around the outside. Moving the battery and charger to the front under a dinette seat moves the (now reduced) weight forward and minimizes the new cable run - less length, less V-drop, faster charging, less cost, less install hassle, less change to the stock camper wiring. The camper loads do not require the upsized wiring, just the path to the battery for charging.

I have read the many Li battery and wire upgrade threads here over time and thought a bunch about how I would do this, what to do about the AC power supply, if anything, solar charging wire considerations, how to avoid changing the camper if possible, being able to return it to stock configuration easily someday and avoid needing to take off the front cabinet face to make any changes if required.

I have one more requirement - power my truck cab radio gear with minimum voltage drop for my high-power RF amplifiers. I think my idea solves this problem as well and requires no change to the camper wiring for it.

I propose locating the battery, or batteries, in standard marine battery boxes outside the camper in front of the wheel wells and the front turnbuckle eye bolts. The DC-DC charger can go in the same area. Mine is waterproof but non-waterproof versions could go into a taller box with battery and charger together, or at least stacked, something you can to with Li batteries vs lead acid type batteries. That truck bed space is normally unused and sizable.

The marker lamp wire and heavy cable from the alternator terminate at the charger, now located in the truck bed for minimum possible length. A very short cable connects the charger to the battery. The charger gets natural ventilation. The space in the camper previously used for charger and batteries are now free for storage. The weight is reduced and moved forward. The stock camper power cable (3 wires) now plugs into the battery box. It can stay stock since the camper loads have relatively low power draw. There is 1 new 10Ga wire added for the solar panel power. Inside the camper minimal and reversible wire changes involve:
1. Bypass the camper isolator.
2. Remove or bypass the existing AGM compatible solar charger and extend the solar panel positive wire through the cabinet to the front and run it outside to the DC-DC charger solar input or separate solar charger. Easy to do since it is a smaller single wire. I would run it in the existing split loom that covers the camper connecting cable.
3. Settle on the best connectors for the above considering weatherproofing. The camper's stock Attwood connector can stay the same since it does not have to carry higher charging current.

As for my radio power in the truck cab, I would run a heavy cable from the battery box into the cab. Very low voltage drop achieved. I would therefore have 1 more battery connector than a normal install, but all outside the camper. Nothing affecting the camper wiring.

The DC-DC charger will trickle charge the starting battery when solar power is available, it may also charge when on shore power also.

The 30Amp IOTA power supply/charger in my 2022 Hawk does not use the IQ plugin of old, it is inside the power supply casing from what I can see with a flashlight. Removing the power supply looks like it requires removing the front cabinet face. I want to avoid that. It will not fully charge the batteries, but it will keep things charged enough and the alternator and solar will top off the Li battery provided the supply exceeds the loads. If this becomes a problem, then the IOTA can be updated/replaced for Li charging compatibility down the road.

Keeping the batteries inside the camper may be an advantage for severe cold weather campers, but an insulated box with heated battery should work fine. Having the batteries inside the camper makes the most sense for selling a complete slide in solution, but I do not think it is the best solution. This solution being easily reversible can appeal to such some buyer's expectations.

In summary, other than running one new solar power extension wire outside the camper, this involves minimal and fully, easily, reversible changes in the camper, frees up space for storage, reduces weight, and uses the shortest length of heavy expensive wire for the best possible charge rate, ease of install, and lowest cost. Existing shore power still works, can be upgraded if needed.

What am I missing?

- Mike
 
If you got the space go for it.

I’d just get batteries with cold cutoff and slap sone external 12v heat pads on the outside with an ink bird controller so you have more control versus built in ones and put them in an insulated box. That’s what I did in my trailer.
 
Overall sounds like a good approach, at least for when the camper is installed to conceal and protect the battery boxes.

There was a thread once that described removing the Iota charger by taking off the black vent grille on the front of the cabinet that ventilates the compartment and using a stubby screw driver or 1/4 ratchet with the correct driver. I have not done it myself, but I’ve had that grille off to install wiring and it appeared doable.
 
I am not a freezing weather camper by choice though anything can happen in the mountains. Heat pads sound good.

I have a tonneau cover on when the camper is off, secure enough, plus the charger will be bolted to the truck bed or under the truck cab rear corner where my ACR is today. That said, with the camper off it would be very easy to remove the batteries, which some like to do for the winter anyway. Just unplug, unstrap and carry them off to the garage.

I had that vent cover off and was able to shine a flashlight in the vent slots and I am pretty sure the IQ module equivalent is in the forward inside corner. Looked pretty hard to get my hand in there to reach the forward bolts, or maybe it was just that it has to be done blind or with a mirror, do not recall. No hurry on that in any case.

Got a few more months to think about it before the camper comes out of garage storage. I am the warm weather type. :).

The bigger decisions are Alaska or CO/NM/AZ this year....
 
For what it’s worth I left the stock converter in my trailer because my solar tops off the batteries fine and I typically boondock.

I my camper build I have a 15amp lithium compatible charger since I was starting from scratch.

Myself and friends have been pleased with our powerurus batteries. Their build quality is better than litime and chins and the price point isn’t much extra.
 
I’m another one who never uses my Iota charger while camping or for the rare cases while charging at home. It doesn’t charge my LiFePO4 battery effectively. I just use a portable Noco Genius 10 amp charger if I need to charge at home. I do occasionally use the Iota at home as a 12 volt power supply while working on camper projects, so I have left it in place. Solar and occasional DC to DC charging from the truck meet all my needs while camping.
 
BB Li batteries have internal temp management system and my 100 aH BB has the internal heating element option which works great...external pads never even considered...I went full Victron electrical and never looked back, great stuff and bulletproof...
 
A lot of the internal pads divert charger power only until the battery is heated to a much higher temp than needed which might be wasting limited charging time. With external pads you can power off the battery as desired (discharge cutoff temp is lower) and as soon as the battery is warm enough to take a charge it will. With external pads you can have them warmed up before a drive (dc-dc charger) or ready at sunrise to accept solar.

Just one consideration.
 
FYI the BB internal heating system in my 100aH Li does not over heat and has an on/off switch or can be left on auto....for me the product really has been great especially with my 350w of solar panels when out in snow...always in cold temps keeps the battery in the correct temp range to receive a charge...otherwise BMS would shut off charging at 25F....

 
FYI the BB internal heating system in my 100aH Li does not over heat and has an on/off switch or can be left on auto....
To be clear I didn't say anything about overheating, I said they heat much higher than needed and I was speaking generally not specifically about the battle born one. Without watching the video I vaguely recall the BB one does pull off the battery which allows more flexibility. However I don't have battle born battery budget and many others don't either so I was speaking in general about the common heated batteries which might sound like a good idea but have draw backs.

For example a battery might have a low temp protection of 32F and a heating function that kicks on below <41F and remains on till the battery is 50-60F. In many cases when the battery is in heating function it is not charging, it doesn't do both, the BMS goes into heater mode and directs charging current to the heater to warm the battery. So the battery isn't charging during that period the battery is heating to 50-60F, which might be wasting charging time available.

With external heaters once the batteries BMS turns off cold protection mode it will allow charging, without needing to heat it all the way to 50-60F. You can program external heaters to continue heating that high if you'd like but it doesn't wait to charge till reaching that high of a temp was my only point. With external heaters you can heat the batteries off their own power and not just an external source. Being able to heat them off themselves would be a wise thing for the OP so he can maintain discharge capability in very cold conditions as they aren't in the heated camper.
 
Close...but while the BB internal heater is keeping my Li battery in the allowable temperature range that permits charging, my solar is putting a charge into the battery...regulates battery temp between 35 and 45 F....BMS only stops charging at minimum and maximum temps to protect the battery...two different systems.

At night or when not needed the internal heater can be turned off; I have found since it is such a small draw in current to leave it on rather than have the battery due to my inattention go below the safe temp for charging the battery if current incoming from solar or DC/DC....I believe for the BB that is BMS shut-off @ 25F.

Also I almost 100% off the grid and with no 110/120 source; so BB set-up makes me self-contained.

BB $$? Not really if you factor in the warranty and reliability. At least that is my take.
 
Close...but while the BB internal heater is keeping my Li battery in the allowable temperature range that permits charging, my solar is putting a charge into the battery...regulates battery temp between 35 and 45 F....BMS only stops charging at minimum and maximum temps to protect the battery...two different systems.

At night or when not needed the internal heater can be turned off; I have found since it is such a small draw in current to leave it on rather than have the battery due to my inattention go below the safe temp for charging the battery if current incoming from solar or DC/DC....I believe for the BB that is BMS shut-off @ 25F.

Also I almost 100% off the grid and with no 110/120 source; so BB set-up makes me self-contained.

BB $$? Not really if you factor in the warranty and reliability. At least that is my take.
I already acknowledged the BB is set up differently and then described how most of the other ones are setup so the original poster is aware. Those ones often do stop charging when the heater is on.

$$$: Yes really, in the last couple years the build quality on some other batteries has gone way up while their price point has come way down. A 100ah BB (not heated) is $750 with a 10yr warranty. A well build import 100ah battery is $210 with a 5yr warranty. A few years ago that import battery was $400-500 and one could potentially argue the value in the BB. But the market has changed. The BB is a premium product, but it is also notably more expensive $/ah and is paying alot of premium (not all) for name at that point. If a $210 battery happens to have a failure in year 6 you're still money ahead (and fresh cells) buying another. I am NOT recommending the bottom dollar import no-name batteries either, there are good quality mid tier ones available.

That is my pragmatic take with budget in mind. Now keeping in mind some folks are paying $40k for a new FWC camper their budget and opportunity cost for $750 is probably a different perspective than my view of $750 as I fabricate my own camper more or less. If spending an extra $500 on something for a minor improvement (or to support US labor) was something that wouldn't be a blip on my budget radar, I'd certainly consider BB still.
 
Last edited:
Be aware of the self drain for heated batteries - for example the BB 100Ah lists their self consumption for heating at 32Ah per day at 15F - so if you were to mount this externally in cold conditions you have 3 days until the battery is exhausted without any actual use - although it sounds like this isn't an issue for the OP. A better system may be a BMS that directs charge current to a heater before charging - that way you would only heat the battery when you need to charge.

Also note that the BB heater implementation is kind of poorly thought out - they switch the positive side of the heater, as a result you can't monitor the current to the heater using your battery monitor - so your SOC reading can be significantly off if the heater is enabled. If they had designed it so that you switch the negative side, you could connect that to the far side of your shunt, and included the heater self consumption in the battery state of charge.

I tend to agree with pods8 - you are paying a huge premium for the marketing/branding that comes with BB.
 
I would be suspicious that a foreign-assembled 100ah battery with a 5 year warranty for $210 is built with used cells. I’m the suspicious type, though. Used cells are more likely to have failures than new cells.

However, if Will Prowse has torn one down and says it was built with new cells, I would believe him.
 
Last edited:
I would be suspicious that a foreign-assembled 100ah battery with a 5 year warranty for $210 is built with used cells. I’m the suspicious type, though. Used cells are more likely to have failures than new cells.

However, if Will Prowse has torn one down and says it was built with new cells, I would believe him.
The wholesale price of LiFePO4 cells has dropped by a factor of about 3 in the last 6-8 years, which is why you can buy a reasonable 100Ah battery for $300.

1738036209523.png
 
Watch the video.....100 aH BB with internal heating and ambient temp 0 F will run the heater for 185 hrs without any incoming charge....or about 8 days...not '32aH at 15F per day...3days'...anyway to each their own....for me Victron and BB have been maintenance and trouble free under very harsh conditions...
 
Watch the video.....100 aH BB with internal heating and ambient temp 0 F will run the heater for 185 hrs without any incoming charge....or about 8 days...not '32aH at 15F per day...3days'...anyway to each their own....for me Victron and BB have been maintenance and trouble free under very harsh conditions...
Wallowa, that is directly from the BB spec sheet for their 100Ah heated battery:

This is an issue with any brand of batteries that use their own power to heat themselves - electric heat uses a lot of juice.

If you are going to use your camper in the winter (which we do) it is best to have the batteries in the living space so you can use the same heat (propane) that you use to heat the camper. I have a heater on my LiFePO4 battery, but have never had to use it, I insulated the door on the battery compartment and it gets enough heat from the camper to be well above freezing when the sun comes up in the morning.

1738037112975.png
 
Last edited:
I would be suspicious that a foreign-assembled 100ah battery with a 5 year warranty for $210 is built with used cells. I’m the suspicious type, though. Used cells are more likely to have failures than new cells.

However, if Will Prowse has torn one down and says it was built with new cells, I would believe him.
They’re new cells and test full capacity. Yes Will has torn down the battery too and was very pleased with the build quality. I didn’t expect prices to drop down so much but they have and completely changed the cost analysis.
 
for me Victron and BB have been maintenance and trouble free under very harsh conditions...
I concur with Victron, well built and their Bluetooth environment brings value and usefulness to their suite of products being used together.

I am sure the BB has performed well, it just would be foolish to assume others wouldn’t also when it has been demonstrated otherwise as the market has matured.
 
Wallowa, that is directly from the BB spec sheet for their 100Ah heated battery:

This is an issue with any brand of batteries that use their own power to heat themselves - electric heat uses a lot of juice.

If you are going to use your camper in the winter (which we do) it is best to have the batteries in the living space so you can use the same heat (propane) that you use to heat the camper. I have a heater on my LiFePO4 battery, but have never had to use it, I insulated the door on the battery compartment and it gets enough heat from the camper to be well above freezing when the sun comes up in the morning.

View attachment 668491
OK....but I am guessing you did not watch the video and his explanation that even when on at zero degrees ambient the heater cycles on and off and is only on 30% of the time...the graph is when heater never cycles but is on the max draw of 1.8Ahs.

The battery box on my Hawk is not insulated from the bed of the truck, it sits exposed to low/high outside temps and when skiing and temps are below zero the box gets very cold....with space heater on and inside temp at sweltering the box remains cold. If I were to cut holes into the front of the battery box and allow heat inside the Hawk to enter the box, then I could keep the battery at a higher temp...or simply use the internal BB heater....with my 350w solar and DC/DC or even when lucky enough to find rare 12v hookups at ski areas [mostly backcountry skiing] the BB heater has never drawn down the battery such that it required recharging. And 12v has only been available on perhaps 2% of my trips in summer or winter; self-contained is my goal.

Bottom line for me is that the combo of BB function and internal heating design, I have no issues with battery drain even down to -15 F.....bigger problem is climbing ladder to remove roof snow load! :cool:

To each their own and personal selection of what works best for them.
 

New posts

Try RV LIFE Pro Free for 7 Days

  • New Ad-Free experience on this RV LIFE Community.
  • Plan the best RV Safe travel with RV LIFE Trip Wizard.
  • Navigate with our RV Safe GPS mobile app.
  • and much more...
Try RV LIFE Pro Today
Back
Top Bottom